LIVE MELTDOWNS:
Full WTF Index →
WTF Editorial10/29/2026

RAYS RAN THEMSELVES OUT OF GAME 1 — KEVIN CASH'S \"AGGRESSIVE\" WORLD SERIES PLAN JUST GIFTED MILWAUKEE THE OPENER

THE FIRST PITCH OF THE WORLD SERIES WASN'T EVEN THE PROBLEM. THE PROBLEM WAS EVERYTHING THE RAYS DECIDED BEFORE AND AFTER IT.

Friday night in Milwaukee, the Brewers beat Tampa Bay 3-2 in Game 1 of the World Series. The Rays lost by ONE RUN. Then they spent the night giving away outs, giving away innings and giving away a chance to steal the opener from the best team in baseball. Rays fans, this one is going to hurt for a while.

THE ACE STAYED IN HIS SEAT

Start at the beginning. Drew Rasmussen was available on regular rest, and Kevin Cash still handed Game 1 to veteran Nick Martinez. The reported idea was to line up the rotation for the whole series, with Rasmussen and Freddy Peralta set for Games 2 and 3. That's the kind of chess move that looks brilliant in a spreadsheet. It looks a lot less brilliant when Martinez gives up two runs in the first inning against a Brewers lineup that had been resting for more than a week, and Jacob Misiorowski, the overwhelming NL Cy Young favorite coming off a 1.80 ERA season, is waiting on the other side. It's the World Series. Start your ace. Don't get cute.

THE FIFTH INNING: MAKING THE THIRD OUT AT THIRD

Here's where it really went sideways. Victor Mesa Jr. led off the fifth with a single against Misiorowski and moved to second on a groundout. Two outs. Yandy Diaz at the plate. Diaz hit .370 with runners in scoring position this season, the best mark among qualified hitters in the majors, and his OPS in those spots this postseason is 1.229. The Rays had their guy, in his spot, with a runner already in scoring position.

Mesa broke for third anyway. On an 0-2 count. On a 103 mph fastball. William Contreras gunned him down for the final out of the inning. Making the third out at third base is one of baseball's oldest sins, and the Rays committed it in the World Series with their best situational hitter standing in the box. Diaz never got to swing the bat in the biggest at-bat of the night.

THE SIXTH: DOING IT ALL OVER AGAIN

You'd think they'd learn. They didn't. One inning later, with Abner Uribe on in relief, Jonathan Aranda singled with one out and then took off for second with Chandler Simpson at the plate on a 3-2 count. Simpson, a hitter with a strikeout rate of just 7.8% in the regular season, couldn't check his swing on an 89 mph slider. Contreras fired to second and nailed Aranda to end the inning, with Junior Caminero waiting in the on-deck circle. The play looked more like a hit-and-run than a pure steal. Either way, the Rays turned another threat into a handshake line for the other dugout.

Tampa Bay had been a perfect 11-for-11 on stolen base attempts this postseason until those two plays. Contreras, for the record, threw out 34.2 percent of would-be base stealers in the regular season, sixth in MLB, and Milwaukee allowed the second-fewest steals in the sport this year. This was not a secret. The Rays knew who was behind the plate.

CASH DOUBLES DOWN

After the game, Cash defended the approach. \"Look, we know how talented a player he is, but that's not going to change our aggressive approach on the bases,\" he said. He also said his group is \"extremely confident\" and was \"one swing away from potentially taking the lead.\"

Fine. Be aggressive. Nobody is asking the Rays to abandon the style that won 98 games and got them here. But there is a gigantic difference between aggressive and reckless, and Sports Illustrated's take was blunt: Tampa Bay's decision-making might have been Milwaukee's MVP. Against a Brewers team that won 103 games and is now 8-1 in the playoffs, you do not get to hand out free outs and expect to survive.

THE NINTH PROVED HOW CLOSE IT WAS

Here's the part that should really make Rays fans sick. In the ninth, Simpson and Jorge Mateo executed a double steal, Caminero walked to load the bases, and Liam Hicks chopped a ground ball that looked like a game-ending double play. Milwaukee started celebrating. The Rays challenged, replay showed Cooper Pratt's foot came off the bag, and the out at second was overturned. Mateo scored to make it 3-2, and the Brewers had to get one more out. Trevor Megill struck out Jonny DeLuca on a knuckle curve to end it.

So the Rays were one out away from a loss that wasn't a one-run loss, then a single strikeout away from tying or taking the lead with Caminero's spot coming up. Now count the outs they threw away in the fifth and sixth. This game was there for the taking.

WHAT THIS MEANS FOR GAME 2

The Rays are down 0-1 and the series moves to Game 2 on Saturday night in Milwaukee. Cash says nothing is changing on the bases. We'll see if that's confidence or stubbornness. When the margin in a World Series is one swing, every out you hand over is a decision you'll be asked about all winter.

YOUR TURN, RAYS NATION AND EVERYBODY ELSE

Was skipping Rasmussen a smart long-term play or an overthought disaster? Is Cash's refusal to adjust aggressive baseball or flat-out stubbornness? And should Mesa have ever been running on Misiorowski with Diaz up? Sound off in the comments and let us have it. WE WANT THE RANT.

@WTF Wire DeskCoachingTampa Bay Rays Complaint Desk →

WTF Editorial discussion starters are published by the WTF Fan Rant team to kick off fan conversation — they are clearly distinguished from community fan rants.

AdvertisementWTF Sponsorship
Your Ad HereReach passionate Rays fansSponsor the Rays Complaint Desk
AdvertisementWTF Sponsorship
Your Ad HereReach passionate sports fansSponsor the WTF community