KEVIN CASH YANKED A SHARP DREW RASMUSSEN AFTER 48 PITCHES — AND THE RAYS' WORLD SERIES DIED IN THE BULLPEN
THE HOOK THAT ENDED A SEASON
Tampa Bay needed a miracle on Wednesday night, and for four innings Drew Rasmussen was giving them a fighting chance. Then Kevin Cash took the ball out of his ace's hand — and the Milwaukee Brewers took the World Series.
The Brewers beat the Rays 4-1 in Game 5 at Tropicana Field to win the first championship in franchise history. Rasmussen had thrown just 48 pitches over four innings. He allowed one run, two hits and no walks, and he struck out four. Cash lifted him anyway. Two innings later it was 4-0, and the series was effectively over.
THE LINE CASH WALKED AWAY FROM
Let's be clear about what Rasmussen actually did. He gave up a run on a Cooper Pratt single in the second inning, then settled in. He was not getting hit around. ESPN described him as looking sharp when he came out. CBS Sports wrote that it is hard to know what more the Rays could have asked of him, and it wondered if he had more in the tank after only 48 pitches.
Yes, Rasmussen was working on three days' rest after throwing 89 pitches in 3⅔ innings in Game 2 on Saturday. MLB.com noted that Tampa Bay announcing him as the Game 5 starter was a surprise, given his injury history and the team's preference for extra rest. So a short leash was always part of the plan. But a potential season-ending game is the exact moment to ask whether a pitcher who is cruising has earned a longer look. Cash didn't wait to find out.
THE BULLPEN CAVED IMMEDIATELY
Kevin Kelly got the fifth inning. He faced five hitters and gave up three hits and an insurance run, including consecutive singles to Milwaukee's seventh, eighth and ninth hitters. David Hamilton's ground ball through the right side of a drawn-in infield scored Pratt. Garrett Cleavinger then opened the sixth by hitting a batter and giving up a double, and another run followed. By the end of that inning it was 4-0 Brewers.
That is the sequence. Rasmussen out, bullpen in, game gone. Cash handed the biggest innings of the Rays' season to relievers who couldn't hold the line.
THE REAL PROBLEM STARTED UPSTREAM
How did Tampa Bay end up here? ESPN reported that Rasmussen was originally slated to start Game 6, and that the Rays used Nick Martinez, their scheduled Game 5 starter, out of the bullpen in Tuesday's 12-inning Game 4 win. MLB.com pointed out that the Rays had used all five members of their rotation in the previous four nights, which meant they had no fully rested starter for Game 5.
Winning Game 4 was mandatory, and nobody is saying otherwise. But the cost of that all-hands approach landed on Wednesday: a Game 5 plan that depended on an ace with a built-in pitch limit and a bullpen that had to cover the rest. Whether you blame the Game 4 usage, the rotation setup, or the hook itself, the decisions all trace back to the manager's chair.
THE FAIR COUNTERPUNCH
In fairness, the Rays' offense gave Cash very little to work with. They managed four hits in Game 5, and ESPN noted they had just 29 hits and 12 runs in the entire five-game series, against 51 hits and 25 runs for Milwaukee. Brewers starter Jacob Misiorowski held them scoreless through 5⅔ innings before leaving with a right calf cramp. CBS Sports pointed to Tampa Bay's lack of home run power and shaky middle relief as what ultimately did them in.
That is exactly the point. When your lineup is scratching out singles and your middle relief is the weak link, you do not take out the one pitcher who has the Brewers in check. You ride him until he gives you a reason to stop.
THE GHOST OF 2020
This is not the first time Cash's hook has been questioned on this stage. Yardbarker's Adam Gretz recalled the 2020 World Series, when Cash pulled starter Blake Snell in an elimination game while he was cruising. The bullpen then fell apart and the Rays lost the Series. Gretz was careful to say the situations aren't identical, and so are we. But a second World Series ending with a manager pulling a pitcher and a bullpen unraveling is going to stick with Rays fans all winter.
WHAT RAYS FANS DESERVE
Credit where it's due: the Brewers were the best team in baseball all year, and they finished the postseason 11-2. They earned this title, and this isn't about taking it from them. It's about a manager who had a pitcher dealing and decided to trust his bullpen with the season anyway.
WAS IT THE RIGHT CALL, OR DID CASH BLOW IT AGAIN?
You tell us. Was pulling Rasmussen at 48 pitches defensible given the three days of rest, or was it managing scared in the biggest game of the year? Would you have let him go one more inning? Sound off in the comments and let's hear the rant.
