FLUSHED — C.J. GARDNER-JOHNSON'S SPITTING APPEAL FAILS, AND THE BILLS HAVE A DISCIPLINE PROBLEM THEY CAN'T WIPE AWAY
THE FACTS, NO SPIN
Here is what happened. Sunday, Oct. 18, at Allegiant Stadium in Las Vegas. The Bills beat the Raiders 33-30. But right before halftime, Buffalo safety C.J. Gardner-Johnson was ejected for spitting toward Las Vegas center Tyler Linderbaum and tight end Brock Bowers. The NFL gave him a one-game suspension on Monday. He appealed it. On Thursday, the league announced that hearing officer Jordy Nelson, jointly appointed by the NFL and the NFLPA, upheld the suspension. Gardner-Johnson is out for the Bills' Week 8 game against the Baltimore Ravens. Buffalo is on a bye in Week 7, so the ban will sit there waiting for him.
THE FLAG THAT GAVE THE RAIDERS A LIFELINE
This was not some harmless side drama. With 20 seconds left in the first half, the Raiders trailed 13-10 and were in Buffalo territory when Gardner-Johnson drew the unsportsmanlike conduct penalty. That flag did more than get him tossed. It moved the ball to the Bills' 14-yard line and set up a game-tying field goal a few plays later. The Bills still won, and the final margin was three points. In a game that tight, a veteran safety handed the other sideline a free gift because he couldn't keep his saliva to himself. Say that out loud and see how it sounds.
THE APPEAL NOBODY NEEDED
After the game, Gardner-Johnson told reporters he would accept the consequences and needed to control his emotions. Then he appealed anyway. Pick one, C.J. The reporting on the incident also says he issued two apologies, with the second coming after the first was widely seen as falling short. Now the appeal is dead on arrival, the suspension stands, and the only thing his challenge accomplished was keeping the story in the news for four more days.
TWO BILLS, ONE SPITTING SCANDAL
Here is where it gets messier. Defensive back and special teams captain Sam Franklin Jr. was also suspended one game for spitting during that same game in Las Vegas. Franklin flatly denied it in a post on his Instagram Story and has appealed too. His agents put out a statement saying, \"We adamantly deny Sam spit at anyone.\" We have not seen a ruling on his appeal as of this writing. If it fails, Buffalo goes into the Ravens game down two defensive backs.
Two players from one team suspended for spitting in a single game. That is not a one-off lapse in judgment. That is a pattern worth asking questions about, and fans in Buffalo have every right to ask them.
BRADY'S RESPONSE: STRONG WORDS, SOFT LANDING
Bills head coach Joe Brady called Gardner-Johnson's actions inexcusable. Fair enough. Brady also said there will be no further punishment from the team beyond the league's suspension, and that Gardner-Johnson will remain a starter when he is eligible to return in Week 9. He summed up the cost this way: \"It's hard enough to win enough in this league with 48 guys, much less 47.\"
Here is the WTF take. Calling something inexcusable and then promising the same starting job on the other side of a one-game ban is a mixed message, and fans heard it loud and clear. Gardner-Johnson signed a one-year deal worth up to $6 million this offseason and has played in all six games. He is clearly valuable. But valuable players are exactly the ones who need to hear that the team's standards apply to them too.
THE BIGGER PICTURE IN BUFFALO
Through six games, the Bills have the league's best scoring offense at 32.8 points per game, tied with the Lions. The defense is a different story, allowing 28.5 points per game and giving up 30-plus in four contests. This team wins shootouts. A defense that already leaks points cannot afford to lose players to ejections and suspensions, and it cannot afford to give opponents free yards and tying field goals before halftime.
The Bills are winning, and winning covers a lot of sins. But the standings are not a character reference, and a 33-30 win where your own safety helped the other team tie it is nothing to celebrate.
WHAT DO YOU THINK?
Is one game enough for spitting at opponents? Should Brady have gone further than the league's ban? Is Gardner-Johnson being treated fairly, or is the NFL right to hold the line? And what about Franklin, who says he never did it? Get in the comments and RANT. We want to hear from every Bills fan, every Raiders fan, and everybody who thinks this league has gone soft on sportsmanship. Let it out below.
